Skip to content

A booking site is not your marketing

Booking sites are very good at reaching people who have never heard of you. They also take a full cut of the guests who already had.

Written by

Adaeze Nwankwo

Founder, Strategy

Published

August 28, 2026

Read

9 min

A resort pool beside a thatched pavilion

There is a version of the booking-site argument that is simply wrong, and hoteliers hear it constantly: leave the apps, go direct, keep the fees. It ignores the thing the platforms are genuinely excellent at, which is putting you in front of someone who has never heard of your property and was not going to.

The useful question is narrower. Of the rooms you paid a cut on last year, how many were booked by somebody who already knew your name?

The billboard effect, in both directions

Being listed drives direct bookings: a guest finds you on a platform, then books on your site. That is real, it is well documented, and it is an argument for staying listed. But the same effect runs the other way: a guest who already intended to book you checks the platform out of habit, finds parity or better, and books there. You pay 18% for a guest you already had.

Both flows exist in every property. The mix between them decides whether the money you hand over is a fair price for finding new guests or simply a leak, and almost nobody measures it.

How to actually find out

  • Split app bookings by whether the guest has stayed before. Repeat guests arriving through a booking site are the clearest leak.
  • Track branded search volume against platform volume. If brand search is strong and direct share is weak, the path is the problem.
  • Test what price matching actually looks like on your own site: what does a guest see in the ten seconds before they give up and go back?
  • Count the steps in your booking form, on a phone, on mobile data. Then count your competitor's.

Commission on a guest who has never heard of you is marketing. Commission on a guest who typed your name is a tax on a bad booking form.

What to do about it

Not a fight with your booking sitesetup. Shift the mix: make the direct path shorter than the platform path, give a reason to book direct that survives parity rules, and get the returning guest onto your own list before they need to search for you at all.

In our experience a property with healthy brand awareness and a six-step booking form can move twenty to forty points of direct share without touching a single platform contract.

AN

Adaeze Nwankwo

Founder, Strategy, RoomReach

Because your guests are already yours

Book your 30-minute growth strategy call.

Bring the number you need to move. We will tell you on the call whether we can move it, what we would fix first, and what it would cost.

  • One flat fee
  • You own every account
  • Senior team only
A warm restaurant interior set for service